To those who are happy with the US troops stationed in Estonia, with the US promises to defend and help us, I strongly recommend an article from the New York Times:
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/26/opinion/the-iraqi-friends-we-abandoned.html?hp&action=click&pgtype=Homepage&module=c-column-top-span-region®ion=c-column-top-span-region&WT.nav=c-column-top-span-region&_r=0
mercredi 25 juin 2014
jeudi 19 juin 2014
Wõitlus maarjalillede wasta
Mind ehmatas periselt ära, kui lugesin Maalehe lisast õpetust, kuda maarjalillikeste wasta piab wõitlema, et neist on raske lahti saada. No kurat on ikka lolle olemas siin Eestimaa pääl. Nigunii niidetakse ruutmiilisi roheliseks kõrbeks, nii et botaanikud juba mures on. Saksa kõrralikkus tõises astmes. Maha maarjalillikesed, wõilillikesed, niimoodu ka sis liblikud, mesilinnud, kimalased. Õige eesti inimese aid ja aiatagune tohib olla ainult roheline kõrrelistekõrb. Rahwussport -- murutraktoriga sõit. Surm sitikatele, konnadele ja kimalastele. Piab otsima üles ühe kõrraliku kabalistide needmise nende kõrralikkude inimeste jaoks. Olen Inglismaal omajagu ringi käind ja maarjalilli on küll pia igal pool muru sees. Ja parkidesse jätetakse niitmata lappisi ka. Ikke liblikate ja tõiste pisitiiwuliste jaoks.
mercredi 4 juin 2014
Geopoliitilised mängud
Et Ukrainas ei olevat kodusõda, vaid võitlus Vene agentidest terroristide vastu. Eks ka Eestis polnud metsavendi, vaid Ameerika imperialistide poolt toetatud ja ässitatud bandiidid...
USA analüütik George Friedman kirjutab:
The single greatest American fear should not be China or al Qaeda. It is the amalgamation of the European Peninsula's technology with Russia's natural resources. That would create a power that could challenge American primacy. That was what the 20th century was all about. Friedman seletab, kuidas hirm alternatiivse võimu tekkimise ees Euraasias viis USA sekkuma kahte maailmasõtta, sõtta Koreas ja Vietnamis. Ning oli aluseks president Wilsoni poliitikale, mis viis impeeriumide lammutamisele, rahvusriikide tekkimisele Euroopas. Parv varblasi ei saa kunagi nii tugevaks kui üks kotkas...
USA analüütik George Friedman kirjutab:
The single greatest American fear should not be China or al Qaeda. It is the amalgamation of the European Peninsula's technology with Russia's natural resources. That would create a power that could challenge American primacy. That was what the 20th century was all about. Friedman seletab, kuidas hirm alternatiivse võimu tekkimise ees Euraasias viis USA sekkuma kahte maailmasõtta, sõtta Koreas ja Vietnamis. Ning oli aluseks president Wilsoni poliitikale, mis viis impeeriumide lammutamisele, rahvusriikide tekkimisele Euroopas. Parv varblasi ei saa kunagi nii tugevaks kui üks kotkas...
Nii püüab USA praegu takistada suurvõimu, riigi või riikide bloki tekkimist Euraasias. Selle tekkimist, mida tema entusiastid nimetavad Eurussiaks. Ameeriklased eelistavad sõdida võõraste kätega ja kui võimalik, kasutada relvade asemel sanktsioone, sabotaaži, propagandat ja muidugi raha. Eurussiale vastutöötamiseks on oluline tekitada lõhe eurooplaste vahel, nende vahel, kellele meeldiks mingi integratsioon Lääne ja Ida vahel, meeldiks liit Venemaaga ja nende vahel, kes Venemaad kardavad. Meie, Ida-Euroopa oleme kiil, mille USA osavalt lööb Venemaa ja "vana Euroopa" vahele. Esialgu on ameeriklastele edu.
Eesti riik loobus oma iseseisvusest, kui 6. veebruaril Eesti koos teiste Ida-Euroopa riikidega kirjutas alla USA Iraagi-interventsiooni toetavale kirjale. Tagantjärele on asjaosalised ise meenutanud, et allkirja andmata jätmine oleks nad jätnud USA suure malaka alla... Siis veel kõheldi, nüüd ilmselt enam mitte. Ometi peaks veidigi arutama, mida USA retooriline ja sümboolne toetus Venemaa ääreriikidele tähendab. Lubatakse meid kaitsta. Ilus. Kuid tegelikult pole asi kaitses. Tegelikult tahetakse Balti riike, Poolat ja teisi kasutada Venemaa ohjeldamiseks, Saksamaa-Venemaa võimaliku liidu torpedeerimiseks. Friedman, nagu mitmed teised analüütikud (endine USA Moskva-saadik Jack Matlock näiteks) osutavad sellele, et USA poliitika eesmärk on ikka olnud Venemaa isoleerimine, Vene mõjusfääri ahendamine, Venemaa liitlaste äraostmine ja äratõmbamine näiteks "värviliste revolutsioonide" abil.
"Aga mis sest!" võidakse öelda. "Oluline on, et USA toetab meie iseseisvust, ükskõik mis motiividel." See ei ole siiski päris nii. Kuna USA nüüd aktiviseerib oma Venemaa vastast tegevust, tähendab see, mis retoorikas on meie kaitsmine, tegelikult meie lükkamist ohu ette. Ning kuigi otsene sõjaline kokkupõrge Venemaa ja NATO, st. USA vahel siin pole kuigi tõenäoline, oleks sellel siin Eestile katastroofilised tagajärjed.
Mis mind kõhedaks teeb, on paljude idaeurooplaste entusiasm, millega USA
strateegilises projektis kaasa lüüakse. Sven Mikser, kes särasilmi
astub NATO sõjalevale ja surub Ameerika kindrali kätt. Kas tõesti
rõõmuga tõttame eesliinile? Mõtlemata, et eesliinil on ohtlik ja veel
üks suurem kaotus võib tähendada seda, et Eesti riiki tulevikus enam
olla ei saa -- rahvast jääb liiga väheks.
Ma tunnen sõjandust halvasti. Kuid on üsna ilmne, et võimaliku sõjalise kokkupõrke korral ei suuda ja ei kavatse NATO Balti riike iga hinna eest kaitsta, vaid siin peetaks taandumislahinguid, takistataks Vene vägede edasitungi, et koguda-koondada jõudusid lääne pool ja siis edaspidi edu korral Baltikum Vene käest tagasi võtta. Mida see meie rahvale tähendaks, pole vaja seletada. Minu esimeste lapsepõlve mälestuste hulgas domineerivad sõjapao-pildid...
Ma tunnen sõjandust halvasti. Kuid on üsna ilmne, et võimaliku sõjalise kokkupõrke korral ei suuda ja ei kavatse NATO Balti riike iga hinna eest kaitsta, vaid siin peetaks taandumislahinguid, takistataks Vene vägede edasitungi, et koguda-koondada jõudusid lääne pool ja siis edaspidi edu korral Baltikum Vene käest tagasi võtta. Mida see meie rahvale tähendaks, pole vaja seletada. Minu esimeste lapsepõlve mälestuste hulgas domineerivad sõjapao-pildid...
Kas oleks võimalik sellist eesliinile, esimese löögi alla sattumist vältida? Kardan, et see on raske, kui mitte võimatu. Oleme juba saanud USA klientriigiks, kuulume ka NATOsse, USA mõjusfääri. Sellest välja astuda ei saa. Kuid muuta saaks siiski suhtumisi, saaksime asju avameelselt arutada. Ja kui meenutada populaarseid Valdur Mikita mõtteid -- saame hoida metsa poole, minna metsa. Eemale suurriikide geopoliitilistest mängudest, vähemalt oma südames. Jätta sportlik kaasaelamine Ukraina praegustele liidritele, kelle tegelikku tausta ja taotlusi me ju ei tea. Kui parajasti ei saa olla iseseisev välispoliitikas, saab seda olla vaimus ja sobival hetkel, sobiva võimaluse tekkides ka saada iseseisvamaks poliitiliselt, liikuda tõeliselt vaba Eesti poole, eemale USA klientriigi staatusest.
Kord Siberis küsiti minult "Ты за кого болеешь?" Ma ei saanud aru, siis ütles mees, et tema "болеет за Киевское Динамо". Mina Kiievi Dünamo fänn ei ole...
P. S. Loen ajalehest artiklit sellest, kuidas Venemaalt kihutati minema tšerkessid. Genotsiid. Tükk ajalugu, ent ka tükk Vene-vastast propagandat. Sellest, mida tegid jänkid indiaanlastega või inglise kolonistid austraalia pärismaalastega, me lehest ei loe. Ikkagi on propaganda teadlik või alateadlik eesmärk näidata, kui halvad ja hirmsad olid Vene valitsejad läbi ajaloo. Sellist propagandat oleks küll targem tegemata jätta.
P. S. Loen ajalehest artiklit sellest, kuidas Venemaalt kihutati minema tšerkessid. Genotsiid. Tükk ajalugu, ent ka tükk Vene-vastast propagandat. Sellest, mida tegid jänkid indiaanlastega või inglise kolonistid austraalia pärismaalastega, me lehest ei loe. Ikkagi on propaganda teadlik või alateadlik eesmärk näidata, kui halvad ja hirmsad olid Vene valitsejad läbi ajaloo. Sellist propagandat oleks küll targem tegemata jätta.
mardi 13 mai 2014
Seven Deadly Sins and Economy
Our economy is based on the seven deadly sins: lust, gluttony, greed, lazyness, wrath, envy and pride. Each one of these sins sponsors and supports a branch of industry. We have many allegorical pictures of these deadly sins from the past, for example the famous painting by Hieronymus Bosch: http://www.wikipaintings.org/en/hieronymus-bosch/the-seven-deadly-sins-and-the-four-last-things-1485#supersized-artistPaintings-195443
Nowadays we could illustrate the deadly sins and their power over our economy with ads, e.g. an ad of fashionable clothing is a good illustration of what is called pride, an ad of an action game is a good illustration of what is called wrath, an ad of sweets or chips points to the sin of gluttony, etc. The main sin of our civilization is probably gluttony, the desire of getting more and more, an insatiable desire that is both satisfied and stimulated by the machinery of modern economy. We want this machinery to work more efficiently, to give us more and more things, more and more pleasure. If it slows a bit, we see this as a disaster. Now, Estonian economy doesn't grow any more, we are in a slump. perhaps it means we are not yet sinful enough. A virtuous person, an ideal Christian is an economic criminal: he consumes little, produces little, and gives things away without asking for pay.
Nowadays we could illustrate the deadly sins and their power over our economy with ads, e.g. an ad of fashionable clothing is a good illustration of what is called pride, an ad of an action game is a good illustration of what is called wrath, an ad of sweets or chips points to the sin of gluttony, etc. The main sin of our civilization is probably gluttony, the desire of getting more and more, an insatiable desire that is both satisfied and stimulated by the machinery of modern economy. We want this machinery to work more efficiently, to give us more and more things, more and more pleasure. If it slows a bit, we see this as a disaster. Now, Estonian economy doesn't grow any more, we are in a slump. perhaps it means we are not yet sinful enough. A virtuous person, an ideal Christian is an economic criminal: he consumes little, produces little, and gives things away without asking for pay.
mardi 6 mai 2014
An Old Poem
About forty years ago I wrote a poem. After the big changes in Europe after the collapse of the USSR I thought it had lost its actuality. Now I feel it hasn't. Plus cela change, plus cela reste la même chose
I READ YET ANOTHER POEM
describing how the end will come
with the nuclear holocaust. Suddenly
I felt very sure nothing such
will ever happen. There will be no big bang,
only some tiny ones perhaps. But surely
a long big whimper: Big powers
insulting one another, serious crises,
disarmament conferences in Geneva,
drug addicts in Washington, dissidents in Moscow,
hunger in Sahel, terrorism in the Middle East,
new cars, fashions and hits,
breakthroughs in computing and space technology,
more handicapped children and mentally disturbed people,
more revolutionary and ecological movements,
fewer trees, fewer birds and less time
to be aware of the high midsummer sky turning slowly
above you and around you and of the mild night breeze
touching gently your hair and stirring up
some strange feelings and childhood memories.
lundi 28 avril 2014
Julgeolek meie-vormis
Öeldakse, et MEIE võime end nüüd julgemalt tunda, sest Eesti pinnal on USA sõjaväeüksus. Mulle ei meeldi see enesekindel meie-vormis kõnelemine. MINA ei tunne end sugugi turvalisemalt kui enne nende ameerika poiste maabumist. Võibolla on muidki selliseid inimesi, kes meie-vormis rahvusliku hirmu või vaimustusega kaasa ei lähe.
mercredi 23 avril 2014
Toward a New Cold Civil War?
Both the First and Second World Wars
have been called Western civil wars. What they were, in essence. The
cold war was different: at least initially it was really a
confrontation between different ideologies, between the liberal West
and messianistic Communism, calling the «servile masses» to the
«last fight». Of course, this internationalist-revolutionary battle
cry little by little changed into a slogan hiding clear geopoltical
aims and ambitions of the USSR, a country that had to realize it had
to take over part of the role the former Russian Empire had played in
the world. Still, it didn't completely renounce the aggressivity it
had inherited from its revolutionary past. It happened only after the
deal between Gorbatchev and the Western leaders in the eighties. Now,
after a pause of about thirty years, a new cold war between Russia
and the West is looming again. It's immediate cause is recent
annexation of Crimea, formally a part of Ukraine, by Russia, and
Russia's other aggressive steps toward its smaller neighbour. Here,
by and large, the Western opinion seems to agree: Russia has returned
to its Soviet past, becoming an expansionist power striving to
reconquer its former sphere of influence. Naturally, this
expansionism must be met with stiff resistance, the West must
mobilize its resources to push the Russians back and show them such a
behaviour is not acceptable.
However, there are some dissident
voices in this choir of Russia-bashers. Former US Secretary of State
Henry Kissinger, former US ambassador in Moscow Jack Matlock and the
CEO of the prestigious Stratfor Institute George Friedman consider
Russian moves in Ukraine a reaction to Western moves, first of all
the expansion of NATO, as gravely jeopardizing its security. In his
book «The Next Hundred Years» Dr Friedman writes that Russia «will
take actions that will appear to be aggressive but in fact are
defensive. It will focus on recovering influence and control in the
former Soviet Union, re-creating the system of buffers it once had.»
This was written in 2009. In the same book, he explains his views
more in detail:
«The Orange Revolution in Ukraine,
from December 2004 to January 2005, was the moment when the post-Cold
War world genuinely ended for Russia. The Russians saw the events in
Ukraine as an attempt by the United States to draw Ukraine into NATO
and thereby set the stage for Russian disintegration. Quite frankly,
there was some truth to the Russian perception. If the West had
succeeded in dominating Ukraine, Russia would have become
indefensible. The southern border with Belarus, as well as the
southwestern frontier of Russia, would have been wide open.»
He
predicts too that the West will not accept this attempts by
Russia to extend its zone of influence: «The United States -- and
the countries within the old Soviet sphere -- will not want Russia to
go too far.» This prediction has come true: the West has vigorously
responded to the annexation of Crimea and other Russian steps in
Ukraine. Mostly, this response has been demonstrative and symbolic.
There are no signs of an imminent military confrontation between
«East» and «West», but the cold war is gaining momentum. And, as
always, the first victim in any cold or hot war is truth. In both
Russia, and in the West, propagandistic discourse is taking over.
Thus, it is very important to listen to other voices, to the
dissidents as the analysts I mentioned.
Now, I have some reason to
include another
authoritative
person to this group of dissidents, namely the former British Prime
Minister Tony Blair. In
his
recent
speech.
Mr. Blair considers the most grave threat to the Westas
well as
to Russia and China, i.e. to the (more
or less) civilized and developed
world, the creeping advance of the islamic extremism. He
says
«that
Western leaders must "elevate the issue of religious extremism
to the top of the agenda". And
they must co-operate with other countries - "in particular,
Russia and China" - regardless of "other differences".»
to
quote from the BBC's summary of his speech. We can see Mr Blair's
speech as a warning to both Western and Russian leaders to put aside
their differences, even the present grave crisis, not to engage in a
new civil cold war, but find ways to counter the danger of
obscurantist
ideology gaining ground in many regions. We chould take this warning
very seriously. In some aspects, the Islamic extremism is similar to
Fascism and Communism. It is a militant ideology that strives to
destroy the old world with its institutions and values and replace it
with something that, for Europeans, belong to the dark ages.
Unfortunately, this ideology is propagated by circles closely
connected with ruling groups in some close allies of the West, as in
Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. For this reason, the West tends to be more
or less silent about the grave abuses (and in some case, the virtual
absence) of human rights in these and other islamic countries and the
spread of the jihadist ideology in the Islamic and even non-Islamic
World. This complacency, understandable
in short perspective, can become disastrous in future. I think the
West and Russia must find ways to reach an understanding. It is not
impossible, and it is important.
I'd like to add a link to a blog by M. K. Bhadrakumar, former ambassador of India i.a. in Moscow: http://blogs.rediff.com/mkbhadrakumar/2014/04/17/ukraine-no-winners-only-losers/.
I'd like to add a link to a blog by M. K. Bhadrakumar, former ambassador of India i.a. in Moscow: http://blogs.rediff.com/mkbhadrakumar/2014/04/17/ukraine-no-winners-only-losers/.
Inscription à :
Articles (Atom)